‘Strong Opinions, Gently Held’: A Product Manager’s Guide

"Strong Opinions, Gently Held" is an essential strategy for product managers working in environments full of unknowns. It's about making informed decisions quickly but being ready to update those decisions as new information comes in. This approach not only helps you navigate uncertainty more effectively but also builds a more collaborative and adaptive team culture.
Table of Contents

Picture this: you’re leading a product, facing the tough task of deciding your product’s next move with limited data and lots of unknowns. This scenario hits close to home in the startup reality of a small company, where quick, informed decisions are crucial despite the constant uncertainties.

This is where the concept of “Strong Opinions, Gently Held” comes into play, offering a strategy to navigate these challenges effectively.

The Philosophy Explained

“Strong Opinions, Gently Held” is about making the best decision you can with the information you have, then being ready to change your mind as new information comes in.

It’s like drawing a map while you’re exploring new territory. You make your best guess on where to go next, but you’re always ready to update your map based on what you find.

The Strong Side of Opinions

To start, you need a strong opinion. This comes from your skills in solving problems, noticing patterns based on your experience, and maybe even a bit of gut feeling. If you’re entering new ground, talking to a few experts can help fill in the gaps.

The point is to quickly form your best guess based on what you know now. For example, you might decide to add a new feature based on your understanding of customer needs and market trends.

The Gentle Art of Flexibility

Next comes the “Gently Held” part. This means actively looking for evidence that might prove your strong opinion wrong.

Encourage your team to challenge your ideas and bring up any data that doesn’t fit. This process helps you refine your opinion, making it stronger and more reliable over time.

Being open to change is crucial here. If new information shows that your original idea isn’t the best, you need to be ready to shift gears.

Why is “Strong Opinions, Gently Held” Effective?

  1. Leverage Your Team’s Collective Wisdom: Sharing your initial strong opinion with your team and inviting their feedback helps you tap into their collective experience and insights. This enriches your decision-making process with diverse perspectives.
  2. Overcome Your Biases: We all have blind spots and biases, like giving too much weight to recent events or wanting our initial ideas to be right. By seeking evidence that challenges your strong opinion, you work against these biases, leading to more balanced and fair decisions.
  3. Have an On-demand Decision: With this approach, you always have a current decision in hand, based on the best information you’ve gathered so far. This means you can make quick calls when needed, but you’re also continuously refining your decision as new information comes in.

Applying It Practically in Product Management

Putting this into practice means starting with a clear, strong opinion whenever you face a new decision. Use whatever tools you have – problem-solving techniques, decision trees, or just your intuition shaped by experience. Once you have your hypothesis, open it up to scrutiny.

Look for data that supports or challenges your view, and be willing to adjust based on what you find.

This iterative process – forming an opinion and then testing it – helps you navigate through uncertainty more effectively.

Tools and Techniques That Can Help

For today’s product manager, several tools can help in applying this philosophy. Use A/B testing to challenge your assumptions with real user data, engage in customer interviews to gather diverse insights, and employ agile development practices to remain flexible and responsive.

The Challenges and Rewards

Adopting this mindset isn’t always easy. It requires being okay with being wrong and being open to changing your mind. However, the benefits are significant.

You’ll make better, more informed decisions, your team will be more engaged and creative, and you’ll be more adaptable as a leader in the face of uncertainty.

“Strong Opinions, Gently Held” is an essential strategy for product managers working in environments full of unknowns. It’s about making informed decisions quickly but being ready to update those decisions as new information comes in. This approach not only helps you navigate uncertainty more effectively but also builds a more collaborative and adaptive team culture.

Next time you’re faced with a tough decision, remember: start with a strong opinion, then be open to change. This balance is key to finding your way through the complex landscape of product management.